NHacker Next
  • new
  • past
  • show
  • ask
  • show
  • jobs
  • submit
Beyond Smoothed Analysis: Analyzing the Simplex Method by the Book (arxiv.org)
ogogmad 1 days ago [-]
Cool paper!

[EDIT: The following is my own clumsy mistake] Minor note: The definition of "mean width" of a polyhedron P in the paper is not translation invariant, and that's confusing. In other words, the mean width of a polyhedron P can differ from that of P+x := {p+x | p ∈ P} where x is some vector. Is that intended? It doesn't agree with how the word "width" is normally used. I would call it a "mean furthest projection". Or maybe "mean peak projection" or "mean shadow"?

yorwba 1 days ago [-]
I assume you're talking about this?

"Half the mean width of a polyhedron P is equal to the expected value of

  max θ^T x
  subject to x ∈ P,
where θ ∈ S^(d−1) is uniformly random distributed with respect to the Haar measure on the unit sphere."

The expression max θ^T x is not translation-invariant: if you replace x with x + ∆x, you get (max θ^T x) + θ^T ∆x. But the expectation of θ^T ∆x is 0 so the expectation of the maximum is translation-invariant again.

ogogmad 1 days ago [-]
I think you're right. Yes, I think it is translation invariant. Ouch, apologies.
1 days ago [-]
Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact
Rendered at 23:16:30 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Vercel.