NHacker Next
  • new
  • past
  • show
  • ask
  • show
  • jobs
  • submit
Decades of Effort Restore Steelhead and Salmon Passage on Alameda Creek (fisheries.noaa.gov)
chihuahua 7 hours ago [-]
There is similar work going on to restore fish passage underneath I-90 near Issaquah, Washington. Although in that case, the part of the streams that's currently inaccessible is less than a mile for most of them, and 2 miles for one of them. It's a major undertaking to restore a stream bed or channel underneath the interstate.

This will benefit Kokanee Salmon, a kind of salmon that spends all its life in fresh water and does not migrate to salt water like most salmon.

In Lewis Creek, they currently have access to only 1/2 mile of the creek, but in 2021 there were about 1000 of them returning (from Lake Sammamish) to spawn.

anitil 6 hours ago [-]
That's really surprising that they could survive with such a small range! How are they counted during their migration?
Dansvidania 5 hours ago [-]
Silly question but if I remember correctly salmon go back to reproduce where they spawned. This suggests that once access is cut up a river, that location loses its salmon (can’t get there, so they don’t reproduce?)

Do they artificially reintroduce the salmon once access is restored or does that “neighbourhood” of salmon somehow survives and keeps trying every year ?

burner420042 5 hours ago [-]
IANAS but my understanding is they keep going upstream - while there's current to push against them - as an instinctual response. I believe water temperature also plays a role.

Salmon hatcheries also artificially boost the quantity of salmon in the stream.

If a salmon hatchery released salmon at the base of a dam, when the fish return and the dam was now gone, they'd just keep going.

However, there's more to it than this, because dammed rivers lacking salmon hatcheries have seen salmon runs start once the dams are removed.

I don't think the old adage that salmon will only return to their original spawning grounds is the whole story.

wahern 4 hours ago [-]
> I don't think the old adage that salmon will only return to their original spawning grounds is the whole story.

Some percentage will just enter a different stream. Straying could be a genetic strategy, imperfect behavior, accidental, or some mix. And they're not all necessarily distinct; e.g. the genetic strategy might simply work by reducing accuracy in locating the original spawning ground.

Consider that even before humans streams and rivers would naturally be dammed, diverted, or otherwise change in a way that made it more difficult or impossible to reach the original spawning ground. What would be interesting is if the ratio of various phenotypes, like those that effect straying, has changed in response to the ecological upset caused by humans.

totalconfusion 2 hours ago [-]
IANAS - I am not a Salmon?
Aboutplants 51 minutes ago [-]
Going to need a response from IAAS
jimnotgym 3 hours ago [-]
Some get lost or stray. It is natures back-up plan.

Stocking can give it a faster kickstart though

metalman 3 hours ago [-]
salmon mostly prefer to return to there natal habitat, but there are a significant number of fish that are wanderers and colinists, so there are now salmon runs happening in far northern watersheds that have only recently become warm enough for juvinile fish. also, fish from clutches of eggs that are transplanted to streams with no fish, become native, which points to the homing instinct bieng re attached with each generation rather than hard coded geneticly, though that may happen in some sub species
burner420042 4 hours ago [-]
> PG&E, Oliver de Silva, and a Bay Area foundation provided the rest of the funding to complete the project.

Why was a 'Bay Area foundation' referenced yet left nameless? I never understand the logic behind this convention..

nkrisc 2 hours ago [-]
Often when you see a vague reference like that it’s typically because the donor requested anonymity. It’s more common with individual donors though.

Sometimes anonymity is a condition of the gift.

bombcar 1 hours ago [-]
It’s perhaps understandable why the Society for the Reintroduction of the Bay Area Gizzly Bear stays under the radar …

(/joke)

durkie 3 hours ago [-]
They may have requested to be anonymous
AdamN 3 hours ago [-]
In this day and age I suspect many environmental and health NGOs are going silent to mitigate backlash.
fragmede 2 hours ago [-]
People treat you differently if they think you have money or did something heroic. Sometimes people don't want to be treated any differently just because you have or did something special. If you liked who I was before you knew I had money, then I'll know you liked me for me, and not my money. The Bay Area foundation might be someone who made it rich in an IPO but doesn't want their friends to know about it.
anenefan 3 days ago [-]
It's so refreshing to see a big company like PG&E reach out to help restore fish breeding ground even if at base level it was a win win situation.
culi 6 hours ago [-]
Well... sure but they created the problem in the first place...

I'd like to live in a world where a company picking up after itself isn't "refreshing"

kiernanmcgowan 9 hours ago [-]
Such good news - for those looking for a relaxing hobby fly fishing is an excellent sport to get into. You spend all day standing in a river trying to out smart some fish and trout are exceptionally beautiful creatures up close.
RajT88 8 hours ago [-]
Agree. I think most fish are beautiful in a way, even the "ugly ones".

What I really love about the fish under discussion here is, for a long time they had no clue why some rainbow trout became steelhead, and some didn't. (They still don't know 100%) Such an interesting story, and a regular rainbow and a steelhead just seem almost like another species - different size, behavior and even taste when you eat them.

bonzini 4 hours ago [-]
People for a long time didn't know what the reproductive cycle of eels is like, because they travel all the way from the Atlantic ocean and back while maturing, so nobody had ever seen a juvenile. Too bad they're critically endangered.
a2tech 4 hours ago [-]
You want to have fun, get two fresh water fish biologists in a room and ask them if steelhead and rainbow trout are different species. Everyone has a different opinion they believe in passionately.
boston_clone 6 hours ago [-]
Not quite as relaxing if you’re the fish!
aaron695 4 hours ago [-]
[dead]
Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact
Rendered at 12:31:56 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Vercel.